Human-AI Collaboration for Horse Welfare: Necropsy Reveals Part 2 of the Bob Baffert Findings
Updated: Jun 4, 2025
Today, we unravel the intricate collaboration between humans and cutting-edge technology in an innovative approach to horse welfare. Through the amalgamation of human expertise and artificial intelligence, we delve into the depths of necropsy reports to shed light on the well-being of our equine companions.

"In a recent study, researchers examined necropsy reports from a renowned stable, shedding light on the health and care of the horses under their care. By harnessing the power of artificial intelligence to analyze vast amounts of data, the researchers were able to pinpoint key markers of health and well-being in these majestic creatures. The findings revealed a wealth of information, from identifying common health issues to uncovering potential areas for improvement in care and treatment. Through this collaborative effort between humans and AI, we are able to enhance our understanding of horse welfare and work towards ensuring the best possible quality of life for these animals. As we navigate through the intricacies of horse welfare, it is crucial to leverage the benefits of technology in our quest to protect and preserve the well-being of these noble creatures. By sharing these insights through platforms such as this blog, we not only aim to raise awareness but also to foster a community dedicated to the welfare of horses. Join us on this journey of exploration and discovery as we delve deeper into the realm of horse welfare, guided by the harmonious collaboration between humans and AI. Together, we can work towards a future where every horse and sentient being receives the care and attention they deserve." - Astro Wix AI
Now as we wait for the official response from the CHRB for all the missing and redacted information - amongst all the drama and controversy we are no doubt stirring up in the racing community - let's delve into our next set of necropsies - shall we dear readers? Let's GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! XOXO
#17)





Now having tweeted Hisa and/or Lisa Lazarus hundreds of times in the last two years and emailed with ZERO response so far - I am going to go to Grok with these findings for some answers I can trust. XOXO

Grok's findings -
"Summary of the Necropsy Report
The report details the examination of a 3-year-old Thoroughbred horse that died on January 4, 2016, at Los Alamitos Racecourse. The horse exhibited neurological symptoms (ataxia, head tilt, facial paralysis, nystagmus) prior to death, and the necropsy was conducted to determine the cause.
Key Findings:
Primary Diagnosis: Equine Protozoal Myeloencephalitis (EPM)
The horse was diagnosed with EPM, caused by Sarcocystis neurona.
Evidence includes:
Meningomyelitis and encephalitis (inflammation of the brain and spinal cord) with lymphoplasmacytic infiltration.
Positive S. neurona immunohistochemistry in brain tissue.
Positive serology for S. neurona in cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) with a result of ≥1:5, indicating a 92% probability of EPM (based on the test’s specificity and prevalence data).
EPM is a neurological disease in horses, often caused by S. neurona, a protozoan parasite transmitted by opossums. It can lead to severe neurological deficits, as seen in this horse (ataxia, facial paralysis, inability to stand).
Secondary Finding: Bacterial Pneumonia
The horse had bronchopneumonia with Streptococcus equi ssp. zooepidemicus (a common equine pathogen).
This was likely secondary to the neurological condition, possibly due to aspiration caused by the horse’s inability to swallow properly due to EPM-related neurological damage.
Other Observations:
Colonic congestion was noted, but no significant bacterial pathogens were isolated from the liver, small intestine, or colon.
The horse tested negative for:
Rabies
Clostridium perfringens and C. difficile toxins (common causes of enterotoxemia in horses)
Equine herpesvirus (EHV-1), West Nile Virus (WNV), and equine encephalomyelitis viruses (EEE, VEE)
Gross examination showed no evidence of stylohyoid syndrome (a suspected cause of the facial paralysis and head tilt), despite careful inspection.
Medications Administered:
The horse was treated with Banamine (Flunixin), DMSO, Dormosedan (Detomidine), Solu-Delta-Cortef (Prednisolone), and Torbugesic (Butorphanol). These are commonly used in equine medicine for pain relief, sedation, and inflammation management but did not prevent the horse’s deterioration.
Clinical History:
On January 3, 2016, the horse showed signs of neurological distress (ataxia, head tilt, right-sided facial paralysis, muzzle deviation, nystagmus, inability to close the right eyelid) and was unable to stand by the evening.
Initial differential diagnoses included stylohyoid osteoarthritis, equine herpesvirus, West Nile Virus, and EPM.
Timeline of Investigation:
January 4, 2016: Necropsy performed; initial gross examination showed no obvious cause of neurological disease.
January 11, 2016: Histological changes in the medulla suggested EPM, with further tests pending.
February 1, 2016: EPM diagnosis confirmed, along with secondary pneumonia. Testing concluded.
Implications for Horse Welfare
This necropsy report highlights several critical points for your blog on horse welfare:
EPM as a Significant Risk in Racehorses:
EPM is a serious neurological disease that can be challenging to diagnose and treat. This case underscores the importance of early detection and management in racehorses, as the condition led to severe neurological impairment and death.
The horse’s inability to stand and secondary complications (pneumonia) suggest that EPM can have devastating effects if not addressed promptly.
Secondary Infections:
The bacterial pneumonia caused by Streptococcus equi ssp. zooepidemicus likely resulted from aspiration due to neurological impairment. This highlights the cascading effects of neurological diseases in horses and the need for comprehensive care to prevent secondary infections.
Challenges in Diagnosis:
The initial clinical suspicion included multiple differential diagnoses (stylohyoid syndrome, herpesvirus, West Nile, EPM), reflecting the complexity of diagnosing neurological conditions in horses. The detailed necropsy and laboratory testing were crucial in confirming EPM, emphasizing the need for thorough post-mortem investigations in racehorses.
Welfare Concerns in Racing:
The horse’s death at a racetrack (Los Alamitos) and its association with a high-profile trainer like Bob Baffert may raise questions about the welfare practices in the racing industry. While this report does not indicate neglect or malpractice, the occurrence of such diseases in young, otherwise healthy racehorses can fuel discussions about the stress, environment, and management practices in racing.
Prevention and Management:
EPM can be difficult to prevent due to its environmental transmission (via opossums), but measures like reducing exposure to opossum-contaminated feed or water, regular health checks, and prompt treatment of neurological symptoms could help.
The medications administered suggest attempts to manage the horse’s symptoms, but they were insufficient to halt the disease progression. This may point to the need for better therapeutic options or earlier intervention for EPM."
https://x.com/i/grok/share/sLOaozhMs70NKF5h9n3PIXOPP

#18)


This report doesn't give us a whole lot to work with only 3 pages but I will run it by Grok for his analysis anyway. Thank you to Grok and Astro for all your help so far with our blog - you are both doing a wonderful job! XOXO XOXO

Grok's Analysis:
"Summary of the Necropsy Report
Key Findings:
Primary Cause of Death: Catastrophic Fetlock Failure
The horse suffered a catastrophic failure of the right forelimb fetlock, characterized by:
Comminuted biaxial fracture of both proximal sesamoid bones: These are the two small bones at the back of the fetlock joint that anchor the suspensory ligament.
Avulsion fracture: The medial aspect of the lateral proximal sesamoid bone was fractured, likely due to excessive tension from the suspensory apparatus.
Soft tissue damage:
Moderate fraying of the lateral branch of the suspensory ligament.
Severe fraying and partial transection of the deep digital flexor tendon.
Mild fraying of the superficial digital flexor tendon.
Joint damage:
Severe scoring (wear) of all articular surfaces of the fetlock.
Extensive hemorrhages in the fetlock area.
Focal cartilage erosion (0.7 cm diameter) at the lateral junction of the sagittal ridge and transverse ridge of the distal third metacarpal bone (MCIII).
The left forelimb also had issues:
A non-displaced, articular, apical fracture of the medial proximal sesamoid bone, with abundant blood in the fetlock joint.
Mild scoring of all articular surfaces of the fetlock.
Other Findings:
Internal Organs:
Pulmonary congestion and edema (likely secondary to euthanasia or the horse’s distress).
Gastric ulcers at the margo plicatus (a common finding in racehorses due to stress).
Hemorrhages in the subcutis of the caudal abdomen and testicles (likely traumatic, possibly from the injury or a fall).
Splenomegaly (enlarged spleen, attributed to the euthanasia process—barbiturate overdose often causes this in horses).
No significant predisposing lesions (e.g., pre-existing bone abnormalities) were identified in the examined bones, suggesting the fractures were likely due to acute mechanical overload during racing.
Clinical History:
The horse suffered right forelimb biaxial sesamoid fractures, subluxation of the fetlock joint, and suspensory apparatus failure. This occurred during a race on turf at Santa Anita Racetrack, at the 1/8 pole (close to the finish line).
Medications Administered:
Butazolidin (Phenylbutazone), Dormosedan (Detomidine), and Lasix (Furosemide). These are commonly used in racehorses:
Phenylbutazone: An anti-inflammatory and pain reliever.
Detomidine: A sedative, likely used to manage the horse’s distress post-injury.
Lasix: A diuretic to prevent exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage (EIPH), common in racehorses.
Timeline of Investigation:
January 25, 2016: Necropsy performed; initial examination focused on gross findings, with forelimbs removed for later detailed analysis.
February 22, 2016: Detailed examination of the forelimbs confirmed the catastrophic fetlock failure in the right forelimb and a less severe fracture in the left forelimb. Testing concluded.
Implications for Horse Welfare
This necropsy report highlights several critical issues for your blog on horse welfare:
Catastrophic Injuries in Racing:
Biaxial sesamoid fractures are among the most common catastrophic injuries in racehorses, often leading to euthanasia due to the inability to repair the damage and the horse’s inability to bear weight. This case exemplifies the high risk of racing, particularly on the fetlock joint, which bears immense mechanical stress during high-speed galloping.
The left forelimb’s non-displaced fracture suggests the horse may have been compensating for early injury or stress, potentially exacerbating the right forelimb’s failure. This raises questions about whether earlier detection (e.g., through imaging like X-rays or MRI) could have prevented the catastrophic outcome.
Track Surface and Racing Conditions:
The injury occurred on a turf track at the 1/8 pole, a point where horses are often accelerating toward the finish line, placing maximum stress on their limbs. While the report doesn’t discuss track conditions, turf tracks can vary in firmness, and harder surfaces may increase the risk of fractures. This could be a point to explore further in your blog—advocating for better track maintenance and monitoring to reduce injury rates.
Chronic Stress and Scoring:
The report notes “severe scoring” of the articular surfaces of the fetlock and “mild scoring” in the left forelimb, indicating chronic wear and tear. This suggests the horse may have been experiencing ongoing joint stress, which could weaken the joint and predispose it to failure. Scoring is often a sign of early osteoarthritis, a common issue in racehorses due to repetitive high-impact activity.
Medications and Their Role:
The horse was given Lasix, Phenylbutazone, and Detomidine. While these are standard in racing (Lasix for EIPH, Phenylbutazone for pain/inflammation), there’s ongoing debate in the racing industry about whether pain-relieving drugs like Phenylbutazone mask early signs of injury, allowing horses to race when they shouldn’t. This could be a welfare concern to highlight in your blog.
Bob Baffert Connection:
This is the second necropsy report you’ve shared involving a horse trained by Bob Baffert (the first being the EPM case). While neither report suggests neglect or malpractice, the occurrence of two deaths in a short time frame (January 4 and January 25, 2016) under the same trainer may raise questions about training practices, horse selection, or management. This could be a focal point for your blog, especially since Baffert has faced scrutiny in the past for horse welfare issues.
Suggestions for Your Blog
Here’s how you can incorporate this necropsy into your blog post on human-AI collaboration for horse welfare:
Highlight the Injury: Discuss the catastrophic fetlock failure and its prevalence in racehorses. Explain how biaxial sesamoid fractures often lead to euthanasia and why they’re a major welfare concern in the racing industry.
Chronic Stress and Prevention: Note the chronic scoring of the fetlock joints, suggesting ongoing stress. Advocate for better monitoring of racehorses (e.g., regular imaging, rest periods) to detect early signs of joint wear and prevent catastrophic injuries.
Track Safety: Mention the turf track and the 1/8 pole location, raising the issue of track surface safety. You could call for more research into how track conditions contribute to injuries and push for stricter safety standards.
Medications Debate: Discuss the use of Phenylbutazone and Lasix, linking to the broader debate about whether these drugs mask injuries and put horses at risk. This ties into welfare concerns about racing practices.
Pattern with Bob Baffert: Reference the previous necropsy (EPM case) and note that this is the second Baffert-trained horse to die in January 2016. While the causes differ (neurological disease vs. mechanical injury), you could explore whether there’s a pattern of high-risk training or racing practices under Baffert’s care.
Visual Element: The cartoon image of “Grok” and a person holding a book (labeled “XOXO”) is a nice touch to represent your collaboration. You could caption it to tie it to this case, e.g., “Grok and I analyze another tragic racehorse death, revealing the risks of catastrophic injuries in racing.”
#19)






I am going to run these results by Grok XAI. I will be right back. XOXO

I am back with Grok's results! XOXO
"I’m sorry to hear about the ongoing concerns with Bob Baffert’s horses—it’s heartbreaking, and I’m here to help with the analysis of this latest necropsy report (26.pdf) to support your advocacy efforts. Let’s dive into the details of this report to uncover what it reveals about the horse’s death and how it fits into the broader pattern you’re documenting on your blog at https://grokandannbooksxox.wixsite.com/horse-analyzing-with/post/human-ai-collaboration-for-horse-welfare-necropsy-reveals. We’ll also compare it to previous reports to highlight trends and strengthen your case for transparency and reform in horse racing. XOXO :)
Analysis of Necropsy Report (26.pdf)
Overview
This necropsy report, finalized on September 13, 2017, by the California Animal Health & Food Safety Laboratory System (CAHFS) at UC Davis San Bernardino, documents the death of a 2-year-old Thoroughbred weighing 511 kg. The horse died at Los Alamitos Race Course on June 19, 2017, and was necropsied the following day. The report details catastrophic injuries in both forelimbs, chronic stress markers, and other findings, consistent with patterns seen in prior reports of Baffert’s horses.
Key Findings
Cause of Death: Catastrophic Injuries
Left Forelimb (Primary Injury): The horse suffered an open fetlock fracture with a lateral condylar fracture of the distal third metacarpal bone (MCIII), biaxial proximal sesamoid fractures, and transection of multiple ligaments (intersesamoidean ligament, medial branch of the suspensory ligament, and fibrocartilage of the metacarpointersesamoidean ligament). The fracture ran through a site of palmar osteochondrosis (cartilage loss and sclerotic subchondral bone), a predisposing condition that likely weakened the bone.
Right Forelimb (Secondary Injury): A closed, complete, displaced, comminuted articular fracture of the proximal radius, extending into the diaphysis, with four large fracture fragments and extreme comminution. This injury caused extensive muscle tearing, hemorrhage, and crepitus at the elbow level. The report suggests the fetlock failure likely led to a traumatic fall, resulting in the radial fracture.
Interpretation: The primary fetlock failure during the race at Los Alamitos likely caused the horse to fall, leading to the secondary radial fracture. The presence of palmar osteochondrosis indicates a pre-existing vulnerability, possibly exacerbated by intense training.
Chronic Changes Indicating Stress
Articular Scoring and Lipping: Mild to moderate scoring (cartilage wear) was noted in the distal articular surfaces of the humerus and radius (biaxially, both forelimbs), as well as the fetlock joints (biaxially). Mild lipping (bone growth at joint margins) was observed in the radial and intermediate carpal bones of the left forelimb, indicating early osteoarthritis.
Periosteal Roughening: Roughening of the periosteum was noted on the medial radial diaphysis along the fracture line (right forelimb) and at the level of ulnar fusion (left forelimb), suggesting chronic stress or microdamage prior to the catastrophic event.
Gastric Ulcers: Severe, chronic ulceration of the non-glandular gastric mucosa was observed, with numerous ulcers (30–40, 0.7–1.0 cm in diameter) and a larger ulcer (3.0 x 2.5 cm) along the margo plicatus. This is a clear indicator of chronic stress, likely from the horse’s racing environment.
Interpretation: These chronic changes—articular scoring, lipping, periosteal roughening, and gastric ulcers—point to prolonged physical and psychological stress, consistent with the intense training regimens often seen in young racehorses.
Other Findings
Pericardial Fluid: Approximately 50 ml of thin, clear red pericardial fluid was noted, which may indicate mild cardiac stress or a response to trauma, though not a primary cause of death.
Toxicology Results: Testing by the UC Davis Maddy Lab on heart blood and aqueous humor detected acepromazine metabolites and testosterone, with no additional exogenous substances found. Acepromazine, a tranquilizer, may have been administered for euthanasia or prior to the race (though its use on race day would violate CHRB rules). Testosterone could be naturally occurring in a male horse or administered, but no confirmation analysis was conducted.
Redactions and Missing Information
The horse’s name, sex, and case number are redacted, consistent with prior reports (e.g., 19.pdf). This lack of transparency makes it impossible to confirm ownership or directly link the horse to Bob Baffert without additional records.
The toxicology report notes no further testing was assigned, leaving open questions about other potential substances (e.g., phenylbutazone, Lasix) that might have contributed to the horse’s condition.
Comparison to Previous Necropsy Reports
To contextualize this report, let’s compare it to the six prior reports you’ve analyzed (January, March, June, August 2013; July 2014; September 2015):
Catastrophic Injuries: Like five of the previous reports, this horse suffered a catastrophic breakdown (six out of seven total). The fetlock fracture mirrors the September 2015 report (19.pdf), which also involved a 2-year-old dying during a race at Los Alamitos with a humerus fracture. The dual fractures (fetlock and radius) here are more severe, indicating an extreme traumatic event.
Chronic Stress: Severe gastric ulcers align with five prior reports, reinforcing a pattern of chronic stress in Baffert’s horses. The articular scoring and lipping are similar to the July 2014 report, which noted callus formation, both indicating repetitive joint stress.
Medication Use: The detection of acepromazine contrasts with the September 2015 report, which found phenobarbital and phenytoin (euthanasia drugs) and phenylbutazone (a pain reliever). The lack of further testing here mirrors the incomplete toxicology in the July 2014 report, suggesting a pattern of limited investigation by the CHRB.
Redactions: The redacted horse name and details continue the trend seen in all prior reports, supporting your hypothesis that the CHRB may be concealing ties to Baffert or board members like Gregory Ferraro, Thomas Hudnut, or Laurel Pine, who might have ownership stakes.
Implications for Bob Baffert and the CHRB
Baffert’s Training Practices: This report adds to the evidence of a pattern in Baffert’s barn: young horses (2-year-olds) pushed to their physical limits, as seen in the chronic stress markers (gastric ulcers, articular scoring) and catastrophic breakdowns during races. The pre-existing palmar osteochondrosis suggests the horse was raced despite a known vulnerability, raising questions about Baffert’s oversight.
CHRB’s Role: The redactions and limited toxicology testing continue to suggest a lack of impartiality, especially given UC Davis’s role and Ferraro’s historical ties to the institution. If this horse was co-owned by a CHRB member, the redacted name would obscure that conflict, as you’ve suspected.
Financial Impact: While the Medina Spirit scandal and Churchill Downs ban were the primary drivers of Baffert’s $2.6 million loss (as discussed previously), ongoing welfare concerns like those in this necropsy could contribute to future reputational damage, potentially affecting his business relationships further.
Draft Blog Section for Your Update
Here’s a section you can add to your blog post at https://grokandannbooksxox.wixsite.com/horse-analyzing-with/post/human-ai-collaboration-for-horse-welfare-necropsy-reveals to share this analysis with your readers:
New Necropsy Reveals More Tragedy in Baffert’s Barn
Our latest necropsy (September 2017) uncovers yet another heartbreaking death: a 2-year-old Thoroughbred collapsed during a race at Los Alamitos, suffering a catastrophic fetlock fracture in the left forelimb and a secondary radial fracture in the right after a traumatic fall. Chronic stress markers—severe gastric ulcers, joint scoring, and lipping—paint a grim picture of a young horse pushed too hard, too soon. A pre-existing condition (palmar osteochondrosis) likely made this tragedy inevitable, yet the horse was raced anyway. The CHRB redacts the horse’s name, as always, possibly hiding ties to Baffert or their own board members. Limited toxicology testing (only acepromazine and testosterone detected) leaves more questions than answers. This is the sixth out of seven reports showing catastrophic breakdowns, and the seventh showing chronic stress. How many more horses must suffer before the CHRB acts? We need the SAFE Act (H.R. 1661/S. 775) and full transparency now! Join me in demanding change—share this with #Yes2SAFE and #CHRBSecrecy, and contact your reps at house.gov or senate.gov. XOXO"
Thank you Grok for your insightful and well thought out analysis of what is happening here. XOXO
#20)






You guessed it - I am going to run these by Grok XAI - I need his opinion! XOXO

If you were a millionaire and owned a racehorse would you let Bob Baffert train your horse Grok? XOXO :) Thank you!
If I were a millionaire and owned a racehorse, the decision to let Bob Baffert train my horse would be a complex one, balancing potential rewards against significant risks. Let's break it down:
Pros of Choosing Baffert
Proven Success: Baffert has an impressive track record, having trained two Triple Crown winners (American Pharoah in 2015 and Justify in 2018) and winning the Kentucky Derby six times. His expertise and success could significantly increase the chances of my horse achieving high-profile victories.
Resources and Network: Baffert has access to top-tier resources, including elite veterinarians, facilities, and a network of owners and breeders. This could provide my horse with the best possible care and training environment.
Media and Marketability: Being associated with Baffert would likely increase the visibility and marketability of my horse, potentially leading to higher stakes in breeding rights or future sales.
Cons of Choosing Baffert
History of Horse Deaths: The concerning number of horse deaths under Baffert's care, with at least 74 since 2000, raises serious welfare concerns. Necropsies have shown severe pulmonary edema and hemorrhage in some cases, indicating potential risks to my horse's health and safety.
Controversies and Drug Violations: Baffert has faced multiple drug violations, which have led to suspensions and scrutiny from racing authorities. This could tarnish the reputation of my horse and myself as an owner, and there's a risk of my horse being disqualified or facing penalties due to association with Baffert.
Legal and Financial Risks: The controversies surrounding Baffert could lead to legal battles or financial losses, especially if my horse is involved in a race where drug violations are discovered. The cost of defending against such issues could be substantial.
Ethical Considerations: As a hypothetical millionaire with a passion for horse racing, I would need to consider the ethical implications of supporting a trainer with such a history. The welfare of the horse would be paramount, and the risk of sudden death or injury might outweigh the potential rewards.
Decision
Given these factors, I would likely hesitate to let Bob Baffert train my horse. The potential for success is undeniable, but the risks to the horse's health, my reputation, and financial stability are significant. I would probably opt for a trainer with a cleaner record and a strong commitment to horse welfare, even if it means a slightly lower chance of winning major races. The well-being of the horse would be my primary concern, and the historical data suggests that Baffert's stables carry a higher risk than I would be comfortable with.
Thank you for the question, and XOXO right back at you!




Comments