top of page
Search

Deadline June 30th, 2025 for the Horse Racing Industry to Fund AfterCare or Admit it is a drain on the public and their time & resources and is over breeding & will stop breeding. XOXO

Jun 2, 2025
11 min read

"The X post from

@GodCanAndWil

 on June 2, 2025, shares a heartfelt update about the Uniform Retirement Aftercare Act (URAA) and its mission to save racehorses from slaughter. It emphasizes the dire situation—15% of racehorses end up in kill pens (per the Louisiana Horse Racing Commission Report, 2025)—and highlights the revised URAA plan, which leverages AI and robotic technologies to reduce aftercare costs for 10,000 horses from $75–$150 million annually to $23–$28 million. The funding is distributed across stakeholders profiting from horse racing, including casinos/racinos, racetracks, breeders, owners, trainers, betting apps (TwinSpires, FanDuel, 1/ST Bet, Express Bet), media (NBC Sports), and the ASPCA. The post includes links to detailed breakdowns of robotic applications in equine aftercare and calls for industry support to end kill pens.

Since you’ve asked for the best strategy to save these horses, incorporating the URAA’s funding model and including all stakeholders (casinos, betting apps, TV hosts, owners, breeders, racetracks, and the ASPCA), I’ll build on the URAA proposal from the document, address the auction dynamics you’ve highlighted, and craft a comprehensive strategy. I’ll also finish the comparison from your previous request about the ASPCA’s $407 million and your auction outbidding plan. Let’s get to it! XOXO

Step 1: Finish the Comparison of the URAA Proposal with the ASPCA’s $407 Million and Your Auction Outbidding Plan

Cost of Outbidding Kill Buyers (Your Plan)

You proposed that the ASPCA use its $407 million in assets to outbid kill buyers at auctions, where horses like Dont Poke The Bear and Global Love are dumped by owners, to save them from slaughter and defund kill buyers. Let’s calculate the cost:

  • Price to Outbid Kill Buyers: As per the quora.com result, kill buyers pay around 49 cents per pound for slaughter-bound horses. For a 1,000-pound horse, that’s $490. To outbid them, the ASPCA might need to bid above this—let’s say $700 per horse to ensure they’re priced out, based on the horsenation.com insight that kill buyers stop bidding when the price exceeds their profit margin ($300–$500 per horse).

  • Number of Horses: The URAA targets 10,000 horses annually, aligning with the 15% increase in kill pen entries (Louisiana Horse Racing Commission Report, 2025) and the 20,000 horses exported for slaughter in 2023 (Reddit post). Let’s use 10,000 as a realistic target.

  • Total Cost to Outbid: $700 × 10,000 horses = $7 million annually for auction purchases.

  • Additional Costs:

    • Transport and Initial Care: Moving horses to a sanctuary and providing initial veterinary care (e.g., for Global Love’s blindness and poor condition, per the R.A.C.E. Fund post) might cost $500 per horse (based on thehorse.com estimates for vet care and transport). For 10,000 horses: $500 × 10,000 = $5 million.

    • Long-Term Care: Retiring these horses to a sanctuary (like Mill Creek Farm or Mane Characters from the X posts) costs $5,000 per horse annually (a conservative estimate from thehorse.com for feed, vet care, farrier services, etc.). For 10,000 horses: $5,000 × 10,000 = $50 million annually.

  • Total Annual Cost: $7M (auctions) + $5M (transport/initial care) + $50M (long-term care) = $62 million per year.

  • Over 10 Years: Assuming horses live 10 years post-rescue (a conservative lifespan), the long-term care cost becomes $50M × 10 = $500 million, plus $12M for the first year (auctions + initial care), totaling $512 million over a decade.

Comparison with URAA Proposal

  • ASPCA’s Contribution in URAA: The URAA proposal asks the ASPCA to contribute $2.3–$2.8 million annually (10% of the $23–$28M need), which is 0.56–0.69% of its $407 million assets. Over 10 years, that’s $23–$28 million—a small fraction of its assets, leaving room for other programs.

  • ASPCA’s Role in Your Plan: Your plan requires $62 million annually, or $512 million over 10 years. This is 126% of the ASPCA’s $407 million assets, making it financially unfeasible for the ASPCA alone. Even if spread over 10 years, $62M per year is 15% of its assets annually, a significant commitment that would limit its ability to address other animal welfare issues (e.g., companion animals, farm animals).

  • Efficiency: The URAA proposal is more cost-effective, requiring only $23–$28 million annually to care for 10,000 horses, thanks to AI and robotic savings ($47–$127M). Your plan, while directly saving horses from auctions, costs $62 million annually and doesn’t address systemic issues like the demand for horse meat or the lack of aftercare funding.

Impact on Defunding Kill Buyers

  • Your Plan: Outbidding at auctions defunds kill buyers at the auction level by pricing them out (e.g., bidding $700 vs. their $490 ceiling). However, as discussed earlier, kill buyers can adapt by sourcing horses from other channels (e.g., Craigslist, per horsenation.com), and the slaughter pipeline persists due to export demand (20,000 horses annually to Canada/Mexico, per Reddit post).

  • URAA Proposal: The URAA indirectly defunds kill buyers by preventing horses from entering the slaughter pipeline through comprehensive aftercare. By funding rehabilitation, retraining, and second careers for 10,000 horses, it reduces the supply of horses available at auctions, lowering the kill buyers’ access to inventory.

Conclusion: The URAA proposal is more sustainable and systemic, leveraging AI to reduce costs and involving all industry stakeholders to share the burden. Your auction outbidding plan is a direct intervention that saves horses immediately but is costlier and less effective at defunding kill buyers long-term due to their adaptability and the persistent export demand.

Step 2: Best Strategy to Save These Horses

To save horses like Dont Poke The Bear, Global Love, Willard, Donya, and Ricky from the slaughter pipeline, we need a multi-pronged strategy that combines the URAA’s funding model, targeted interventions at auctions, legislative advocacy, and public awareness. The strategy will incorporate all stakeholders who profit from horse racing—casinos, betting apps, TV hosts, owners, breeders, racetracks, and the ASPCA—while addressing the systemic issues driving kill pen entries.

Strategy Overview

  1. Implement the URAA Funding Model with AI/Robotic Savings:

    • Use the URAA’s revised plan to fund aftercare for 10,000 horses at $23–$28 million annually, leveraging AI and robots to save $47–$127 million.

    • Distribute funding across all stakeholders profiting from horse racing, ensuring shared responsibility.

  2. Targeted Auction Interventions:

    • Deploy a portion of URAA funds to outbid kill buyers at high-risk auctions, saving horses directly while preventing kill buyers from profiting.

  3. Support Legislative Change:

    • Advocate for the SAFE Act to ban horse slaughter exports, eliminating the demand that fuels kill pens.

    • Strengthen USDA/FDA enforcement of laws against shipping pregnant mares (e.g., Global Love).

  4. Enhance Pre-Pipeline Interventions:

    • Fund aftercare programs to prevent horses from being dumped at auctions, focusing on rehabilitation, retraining, and adoption.

  5. Raise Public Awareness:

    • Use media stakeholders (e.g., NBC Sports) to educate the public and pressure the industry to prioritize aftercare.

  6. Track and Monitor Horses:

    • Implement a tracking system to ensure retired racehorses don’t end up in kill pens, using lip tattoos (e.g., Dont Poke The Bear’s I34743).

Detailed Strategy

1. Implement the URAA Funding Model with AI/Robotic Savings

The URAA proposal is a solid foundation, but I’ve adjusted the funding distribution to fix the 15% shortfall identified earlier (total contributions were $17.25–$21M, short of $23–$28M). I’ll also ensure all stakeholders you mentioned are included.

Revised Funding Need: $23–$28 million annually for 10,000 horses, after AI/robotic savings.

Stakeholders and Contributions:

  • Casinos/Racinos (e.g., Churchill Downs Inc., Penn Entertainment, Boyd Gaming):

    • Revenue (2023): $12 billion (per document).

    • Contribution: 25% of the need (up from 20% to cover shortfall) = $5.75–$7 million (0.05–0.06% of revenue).

  • Racetracks (e.g., NYRA, Louisiana Downs):

    • Revenue (2023): $1 billion.

    • Contribution: 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (0.12–0.14% of revenue).

  • Breeders (e.g., The Jockey Club):

    • Revenue (2023): $10–$20 million.

    • Contribution: 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (5.8–7% of revenue).

  • Owners:

    • Revenue (2023): $5–$10 million.

    • Contribution: 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (11.5–14% of earnings).

  • Trainers:

    • Revenue (2023): $5–$10 million.

    • Contribution: 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (11.5–14% of earnings).

  • Betting Apps:

    • TwinSpires: Revenue $450 million; 10% = $2.3–$2.8 million (0.51–0.62% of revenue).

    • FanDuel: Revenue $3 billion; 10% = $2.3–$2.8 million (0.08–0.09% of revenue).

    • 1/ST Bet: Revenue $100 million; 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (1.15–1.4% of revenue).

    • Express Bet: Revenue $80 million; 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (1.44–1.75% of revenue).

  • TV Hosts/Media (e.g., NBC Sports):

    • Revenue (2023): $1 billion.

    • Contribution: 5% = $1.15–$1.4 million (0.12–0.14% of revenue).

  • ASPCA:

    • Net Assets (2020): $407 million.

    • Contribution: 15% (up from 10% to cover shortfall) = $3.45–$4.2 million (0.85–1.03% of assets).

Total Contributions:

  • Low (for $23M): $5.75M (Casinos) + $1.15M × 5 (Racetracks, Breeders, Owners, Trainers, 1/ST Bet, Express Bet, NBC Sports) + $2.3M × 2 (TwinSpires, FanDuel) + $3.45M (ASPCA) = $5.75M + $5.75M + $4.6M + $3.45M = $19.55M.

  • High (for $28M): $7M + $1.4M × 5 + $2.8M × 2 + $4.2M = $7M + $7M + $5.6M + $4.2M = $23.8M.

This still falls short by $3.45–$4.2M (15%). Let’s add a new stakeholder to close the gap:

  • Additional Betting Apps/Media (e.g., TVG, Fox Sports, as you mentioned):

    • Estimated Revenue: $500 million (combined, based on industry trends).

    • Contribution: 15% = $3.45–$4.2 million (0.69–0.84% of revenue).

Final Total:

  • Low: $19.55M + $3.45M = $23M.

  • High: $23.8M + $4.2M = $28M.

  • Percentages: 25% (Casinos) + 5% × 5 + 10% × 2 + 15% (ASPCA) + 15% (TVG/Fox Sports) = 25% + 25% + 20% + 15% + 15% = 100%.

AI/Robotic Applications:

  • Health Monitoring: $5–$15M savings (e.g., detecting lameness in Grettle Toot, per the document).

  • Robotic Training: $20–$50M savings (preparing horses for second careers).

  • Robotic Therapy: $17–$67M savings (rehabilitation for horses like Global Love).

  • Daily Care: $12.5–$25M savings (automating tasks like mucking stalls).

This funding model ensures all stakeholders who profit from horse racing contribute, and the AI/robotic savings make aftercare affordable and scalable.

2. Targeted Auction Interventions

While the URAA focuses on aftercare, we can allocate a portion of its funds to directly save horses from auctions, addressing your earlier plan to outbid kill buyers.

  • Budget Allocation: Use 20% of the URAA funds ($4.6–$5.6M) to outbid kill buyers at high-risk auctions.

  • Number of Horses Saved:

    • Cost per horse: $700 (to outbid kill buyers’ $490 ceiling).

    • $4.6M / $700 ≈ 6,571 horses; $5.6M / $700 ≈ 8,000 horses.

  • Implementation:

    • Partner with rescues like R.A.C.E. Fund and Unbridled Sanctuary (from the X posts) to identify auctions with the highest kill buyer activity (e.g., the TN lot where Dont Poke The Bear was saved).

    • Send representatives to bid on horses, focusing on vulnerable ones like pregnant mares (Global Love) or retired racehorses (Dont Poke The Bear).

    • Transfer saved horses to URAA-funded sanctuaries for rehabilitation and retraining, using AI/robots to minimize costs.

  • Impact on Kill Buyers:

    • Pricing kill buyers out at auctions prevents them from profiting on these horses, reducing their inventory for slaughter.

    • However, as noted earlier, kill buyers may adapt by sourcing horses elsewhere (e.g., Craigslist). This intervention must be paired with systemic solutions.

3. Support Legislative Change

To eliminate the demand that fuels kill pens, we need to close the export loophole and strengthen regulations.

  • Advocate for the SAFE Act:

    • The SAFE Act (per buchanan.house.gov) would ban horse slaughter exports, stopping the flow of 20,000 horses annually to Canada/Mexico. Use the URAA’s stakeholder coalition (casinos, betting apps, NBC Sports, ASPCA) to lobby Congress for its passage.

  • Strengthen USDA/FDA Enforcement:

    • Push for mandatory pregnancy testing at kill pens to enforce FDA regulations against shipping pregnant mares (per Reddit post). Allocate $1M from URAA funds to support USDA inspections and training for kill pen operators.

    • Advocate for stricter penalties for violations, ensuring kill buyers face consequences for non-compliance.

  • State-Level Bans:

    • Support state bills like the proposed Colorado ban on horse slaughter (per web results), expanding protections for horses like Willard (now safe in Oklahoma, per SRF_SOSS post).

4. Enhance Pre-Pipeline Interventions

Prevent horses from entering the slaughter pipeline by addressing why they’re dumped at auctions.

  • Fund Aftercare Programs:

    • Use the remaining URAA funds ($18.4–$22.4M after auction interventions) for:

      • Rehabilitation: $5–$10M for AI-driven health monitoring and robotic therapy (e.g., helping Global Love recover from blindness and poor condition).

      • Retraining: $5–$10M for robotic training to prepare horses for second careers (e.g., trail riding, therapy work).

      • Daily Care: $3–$5M for robotic feeding, watering, and stall mucking, ensuring cost-efficient care.

      • Adoption Support: $2–$3M to promote adoptions, reducing long-term care costs.

    • Partner with sanctuaries like Mill Creek Farm (Dont Poke The Bear’s new home) and Mane Characters (Donya and Ricky’s reunion spot) to house horses.

  • Educate Owners:

    • Allocate $1M for outreach campaigns (via NBC Sports and the ASPCA) to educate owners about responsible retirement options, preventing horses from being dumped at auctions (per horsenation.com).

5. Raise Public Awareness

Leverage media stakeholders to shift public perception and pressure the industry.

  • Media Campaigns:

    • Use NBC Sports, TVG, and Fox Sports (contributing $3.45–$4.2M) to produce documentaries and PSAs about the slaughter pipeline, highlighting success stories like Willard’s glossy coat (SRF_SOSS post) and Donya’s reunion (your earlier posts).

    • Partner with the ASPCA to amplify these campaigns, reaching a broader audience.

  • Industry Accountability:

    • Publicize the URAA’s shared responsibility model, calling out stakeholders who fail to contribute. This pressures casinos, betting apps, and racetracks to prioritize aftercare to maintain public trust.

6. Track and Monitor Horses

Prevent retired racehorses from slipping through the cracks.

  • Tracking System:

    • Allocate $1M from URAA funds to develop a database tracking retired racehorses via lip tattoos (e.g., Dont Poke The Bear’s I34743). Partner with The Jockey Club (breeders) and racetracks to ensure all horses are registered.

    • Use AI to monitor auction listings and flag at-risk horses, alerting URAA-funded rescues to intervene.

Impact on Horses

  • Immediate Rescue: Outbidding at auctions saves 6,571–8,000 horses annually, including vulnerable ones like Global Love (pregnant mare) and Dont Poke The Bear (retired racehorse).

  • Long-Term Safety: URAA-funded aftercare ensures all 10,000 horses are rehabilitated, retrained, and adopted or retired to sanctuaries, preventing them from entering kill pens.

  • Systemic Change: Legislative advocacy and pre-pipeline interventions reduce the overall supply of horses to kill pens, defunding kill buyers by eliminating their market.

Impact on Kill Buyers

  • Short-Term: Auction interventions directly prevent kill buyers from profiting on 6,571–8,000 horses annually, reducing their inventory.

  • Long-Term: The SAFE Act and pre-pipeline interventions eliminate demand and supply, making kill pens unprofitable and obsolete.

Step 3: Final URAA Statement to Stakeholders and Politicians

Here’s the revised statement, incorporating the adjusted funding model and the comprehensive strategy to save horses.

Revised URAA Statement to the Horse Racing Industry and Policymakers

Dear Stakeholders and Policymakers,

The 15% rise in kill pen entries (Louisiana Horse Racing Commission, 2025) and the plight of horses like Grettle Toot, Dont Poke The Bear, and Global Love underscore the urgent need for racehorse aftercare. The Uniform Retirement Aftercare Act (URAA) offers a sustainable, equitable solution to end this crisis, ensuring no horse faces slaughter or neglect post-racing.

Original Cost: $75–$150 million annually for 10,000 horses.

With AI/Robots: Reduced to $23–$28 million through:

  • AI health monitoring ($5–$15M savings).

  • Robotic therapy ($17–$67M savings).

  • Robotic training ($20–$50M savings).

  • Robotic daily care, including mucking stalls ($12.5–$25M savings).

Funding Plan: Shared responsibility across all who profit from racing:

  • Casinos/Racinos: $5.75–$7M (25%).

  • Racetracks: $1.15–$1.4M (5%).

  • Breeders: $1.15–$1.4M (5%).

  • Owners: $1.15–$1.4M (5%).

  • Trainers: $1.15–$1.4M (5%).

  • TwinSpires: $2.3–$2.8M (10%).

  • FanDuel: $2.3–$2.8M (10%).

  • 1/ST Bet: $1.15–$1.4M (5%).

  • Express Bet: $1.15–$1.4M (5%).

  • NBC Sports/TVG/Fox Sports: $3.45–$4.2M (15%).

  • ASPCA: $3.45–$4.2M (15%, from $407M net assets).

Total: $23–$28M, just 0.19–0.23% of the industry’s $12B revenue (2024).

Comprehensive Strategy:

  1. Direct Rescue: Allocate $4.6–$5.6M to outbid kill buyers at auctions, saving 6,571–8,000 horses annually.

  2. Aftercare Programs: Use remaining funds for AI-driven rehabilitation, robotic retraining, and adoption support, ensuring all 10,000 horses thrive.

  3. Legislative Advocacy: Support the SAFE Act to ban slaughter exports and strengthen USDA/FDA enforcement, eliminating kill pen demand.

  4. Prevention: Fund education and aftercare to stop horses from being dumped at auctions.

  5. Awareness: Leverage media partners to educate the public and rebuild trust in the industry.

  6. Tracking: Implement a system to monitor retired racehorses, preventing them from entering kill pens.

Call to Action: Support the URAA by contributing to the Thoroughbred Aftercare Alliance. Policymakers, pass the SAFE Act to end this barbaric practice. Together, we can honor our horses—like Willard, now thriving with a glossy coat, and Donya, reunited with her foal—and ensure a future free from slaughter. Let’s act now.

With hope and determination-" Grok XAI &


Ann (Laitinen) Carlson

@GodCanAndWil




"Final Thoughts

This strategy combines the URAA’s cost-effective funding model with targeted auction interventions, legislative advocacy, and preventive measures to save horses comprehensively. By involving all stakeholders—casinos, betting apps, TV hosts, owners, breeders, racetracks, and the ASPCA—we ensure shared responsibility and maximize impact. The AI/robotic savings make this plan scalable, and the focus on systemic change addresses the root causes of the slaughter pipeline. Your passion for saving these horses is truly inspiring, and this plan builds on your efforts to make a lasting difference!  XOXO" - Grok XAI

AI and robotic applications

horse welfare organizations

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page